10 Pros and Cons of Meal Replacement Shakes | Benefits & Risks


Pros and Cons of Meal Replacement Shakes

Meal replacement shakes are becoming increasingly popular among those who want to lose weight. After all, they offer a good amount of nutrition for the person that is on the go. However, they come with their own set of benefits and risks.

The pros of meal replacement shakes are that they are convenient, easy to make, and effective in weight reduction and weight maintenance. On the other hand, the cons of meal replacement shakes are that they are not a long-term solution and don’t fix unhealthy eating habits. 

This article discusses the pros and cons of meal replacement shakes, the difference between a meal replacement shake and a protein shake, and how to choose the best meal replacement shake.

What Are Meal Replacement Shakes?

Whether bottled or canned, meal replacement shakes are an easy way to get healthy and shed weight. They contain a wide variety of healthy ingredients and are often used for maintenance or weight loss.

Meal replacement shakes have been formulated to give your body nutrition, equivalent to eating a meal but with fewer fats and calories.

Pros of Meal Replacement Shakes

1. A Good Source of Protein

Many meal replacement shakes are a good source of protein, playing an important role in weight loss.

Protein keeps you satiated and full for a long period of time. In fact, higher protein diets are linked with increased fullness and reductions in hunger throughout the day.

According to one study (The effects of consuming frequent, higher protein meals on appetite and satiety during weight loss in overweight/obese men), men who consumed a high-protein diet experienced fewer cravings and a reduction in late-night desire to eat than their counterparts who ate a moderate amount of protein.

Other than that, high-protein diets help improve weight maintenance, reduce body fat, and increase lean body mass.

In one study (The effPostprandial thermogenesis is increased 100% on a high-protein, low-fat diet versus a high-carbohydrate, low-fat diet in healthy, young womenects of consuming frequent, higher protein meals on appetite and satiety during weight loss in overweight/obese men), researchers fed healthy women either a high-carbohydrate or a high-protein meal. They found that after 2.5 hours of eating, thermogenesis was doubled in women who consumed the high-protein meal, versus women who consumed the high-carbohydrate meal.

Thermogenesis is the process of production of heat in your body. Your body requires calories (energy) to generate heat. This is why increased thermogenesis equals increased energy expenditure and will cause weight loss over time.

In another study (A controlled trial of protein enrichment of meal replacements for weight reduction with retention of lean body mass) that compared high-carb meal replacements and high-protein meal replacements, both groups experienced similar weight loss at 12 weeks.

However, the study found that participants in the high-protein group lost more body fat than those in the high-carb group.

It’s important to know that some meal replacement shakes contain higher amounts of protein than others. Therefore, you should choose a meal replacement shake that is low in sugar but high in protein.

2. Contain Added Superfoods

Some of the more premium meal replacement shakes also contain added superfood blends, helping you get the health benefits of vegetables and fruits within the formula. This provides not only extra minerals and vitamins but also phytochemicals and antioxidants, which are beneficial for your health.

Phytochemicals are naturally occurring compounds found in plants that contribute to their smell, taste, and color. These compounds may help decrease your risk for certain cancers.

Plus, they can also reduce your risk of heart disease, high blood pressure, and diabetes.

3. Help With Faster Weight Loss

Meal replacement shakes can help you feel more satisfied and full while eating fewer calories. According to many studies, substituting two meals daily with a shake may help you lose weight faster.

According to an analysis, people who followed a partial meal replacement plan achieved a greater weight loss at three months than their counterparts who followed a low-calorie diet plan.

Also, according to one study, participants who consumed a shake lost a similar weight as people who ate a low-fat diet.

These shakes have also been found to promote weight loss in people with diabetes.

A clinical trial analyzed the safety of using liquid meal replacements for weight loss in people with diabetes. It found that people who took meal replacements showed a reduction in LDL (bad) cholesterol levels and body weight.

Apart from this, meal replacements can also help maintain weight loss after attaining your weight loss goals.

4. Provide More Nutrients Than Traditional Diets

Meal replacement shakes offer nutrients that you should get from food. When you cut back on high-calorie foods, it can be hard to get all of the nutrients you need from your diet.

Meal replacement shakes are often fortified with fiber, protein, minerals, and vitamins, which might help fill a nutrient gap while reducing your calorie intake.

Most shakes are rich in nutrients such as vitamin D, iron, calcium, and potassium, which many people aren’t getting in sufficient amounts. In addition to keeping your bones strong, calcium helps maintain your muscle function and heart rhythm.

How much calcium you require depends on age:

  • Adults aged 50 or below need 1,000 milligrams of calcium every day
  • Adults aged above 50 years need 1,200 milligrams of calcium per day.

Potassium is essential for the kidneys, heart, and other organs to work normally. Low potassium is linked with a risk of many disorders and diseases.

You need iron to produce hemoglobin, a part of red blood cells that transport oxygen throughout your body.

And vitamin D is important for maintaining healthy and strong bones.

5. Help You Avoid Unhealthy Processed Foods

Meal replacement shakes are convenient and easy to make, and they may help you avoid unhealthy processed foods.

One of the barriers to losing weight is the time it takes to cook a healthy meal. It’s easier and convenient to grab fast food or processed food when you are busy or stressed. However, processed foods can sabotage your weight loss efforts.

In addition to lacking essential nutrients, most processed foods contain high amounts of refined carbohydrates, artificial ingredients, and sugar.

Moreover, diets high in sugar and refined carbohydrates have been associated with mood disorders, hyperactivity, obesity, heart disease, and high blood pressure.

Furthermore, processed foods that are high in sugar, salt, and fat activate your brain’s pleasure centers, causing overeating.

On the other hand, meals prepared from whole foods are great for losing weight, but that is not always possible with a hectic schedule. Meal replacement shakes are easy to make and a healthier alternative to processed foods.

6. Curb Your Sweet Tooth

The best meal replacement shakes do not contain artificial sweeteners or sugar. They can help you rid yourself of your dangerous and unhealthy sugar addiction.

The best meal replacement shakes will healthily satisfy your sweet tooth by containing sugar-free alternatives like Stevia.

Stevia does not contain artificial ingredients, calories, and carbohydrates and is about 200 times sweeter than table sugar.

7. Revs Up Metabolism

Adding protein to your diet is a good way to help increase your metabolism. Boosting your metabolism is one of the important steps to losing weight, as it lets you burn more calories.

Your body uses calories to digest and metabolize the food. This is known as the thermic effect of food (TEF), and it’s higher for protein (20 to 30%) than fat (0-3%) or carbohydrates (5-10%).

A high protein intake tends to increase metabolism due to the high thermic effect and other factors. It makes you burn more fat, even during sleep.

So, you should aim for a meal replacement shake with 15-20 g (0.52-0.70 oz.) of protein. The most common protein sources are whey, pea protein, rice protein, quinoa, and in many meal replacement shakes.

In addition, studies show that they can significantly help build lean muscle and lose weight.

Here are some of the benefits of whey protein:

  • Promotes the growth of muscles
  • May reduce blood pressure
  • May help decrease inflammation
  • May help with weight loss

Cons of Meal Replacement Shakes

8. They Don’t Change Your Eating Habits

Diets don’t help with weight loss in the long-term.

Weight loss for the long-term needs permanent changes in activity and eating patterns. While drinking shakes can help you shed body weight, they don’t change your eating habits.

You will likely gain your weight back if you go back to your unhealthy eating habits.

9. They Are Not a Long-Term Solution

Meal replacement shakes are not a long-term solution for weight loss and weight maintenance.

While many meal replacement shakes offer vital nutrients, they cannot replace a healthy, balanced diet of whole foods.

Whole foods are rich in enzymes, plant compounds, antioxidants, minerals, and vitamins that are hard to put into a meal replacement bottle.

In fact, whole foods, such as legumes, vegetables, and fruits, contain more fiber than meal replacement shakes.

10. Some Meal Replacement Shakes Contain Unhealthy Ingredients

Many shakes are prepared with wholesome ingredients, such as vegetables, fruits, and whole grains.

However, some meal replacement shakes contain unhealthy ingredients, such as chemical preservatives, artificial flavors, corn syrup, and added sugars.

Added sugar is high in calories and contains no essential nutrients. Regularly consuming added sugar in excess can cause compulsive overeating.

Plus, it is associated with conditions such as inflammatory diseases, type 2 diabetes, metabolic syndrome, and obesity.

Unfortunately, some meal replacement shakes contain more sugar than protein. So, you should always check the label before buying a meal replacement shake.

It’s important to know that a healthy shake should contain only a few grams of sugar.

Difference Between Protein Shakes and Meal Replacement Shakes

Meal replacement shakes and protein shakes are made for different goals and vary in nutritional composition.

Protein shakes consist only of protein, usually specific amino acids or whey protein, with no additional nutrients. Protein shakes are used for muscle gain and athletic performance. They contain about 25 grams (0.88 oz.) of protein per serving.

These shakes are formulated to be a supplement in addition to multiple meals throughout the day. It’s important to know that they should not be used as a substitute for a meal.

On the other hand, meal replacement shakes contain protein, less than a protein shake. They have a protein content of 10 grams (0.35 oz.) per serving.

However, they are fortified with minerals and vitamins and offer more carbohydrates and fiber per serving than protein shakes.

What Should You Look for in a Shake?

There are a few things you need to consider when buying a meal replacement shake.

You can easily differentiate between a bad and good shake by looking at the nutrition label. You should look for a balance of protein, fats, and carbohydrates.

A meal replacement shake should contain 10-13 g (0.35-0.45 oz.) of healthy fat, 18 vitamins and minerals, 20 g (0.88 oz.) of protein, and a good amount of fiber per serving.

Do not purchase a meal replacement shake containing added sugars, artificial flavors, or over 400 calories per serving.

You can also use added ingredients to supplement your meal replacement shake for more benefits and flavor.

You can add spinach, which is rich in vitamin C and will increase your body’s ability to absorb nutrients. Greek yogurt will add more vitamin B12, zinc, protein, vitamin B6, potassium, and calcium.

Adding a very small amount of cinnamon can have antioxidant benefits, and decrease inflammation and blood pressure.

You can also add ground flaxseed, nut butter, nuts, and shredded cabbage to your meal replacement shake for protein and fiber.

If you want to use green smoothies as a shake, combine a superfood, fruit, a liquid base, and leafy green vegetables. You can also add an optional protein if you want.

Superfood ideas include ginger, turmeric, cinnamon, chia seeds, and ground flaxseed. Proteins could be avocado, seed butter, or protein powder. You can choose strawberries, blueberries, mango, or bananas for fruit.

Liquid-base options include plain water, pomegranate juice, coconut water, coconut milk, or almond milk. And leafy green veggies ideas include lettuce, chard, collard greens, or kale.

When Should You Take Meal Replacement Shakes?

Breakfast

Do you skip your breakfast too often? If you do, you must know that skipping breakfast makes your body crave foods that are high in fat and sugar.

Also, not having your breakfast intensifies your hunger pangs, which, in turn, increases your calorie intake.

If you are in a hurry and have no time to prepare breakfast, you should consider having a meal replacement shake.

Article to check out: Are Meal Replacement Shakes Good for Breakfast?

Workout

Most meal replacement shakes are rich in whey protein that aids in the repair and building of your muscles. Taking a shake as part of your workout meal will supply your muscles with amino acids vital to your workout recovery and weight loss.

You can also add fruits and vegetables to your shakes to meet your nutrient and energy requirements throughout the day.

Article to check out: Meal Replacement Shakes: Drink BEFORE or AFTER Workout?

Snack

You can also have a meal replacement shake as a snack. Some days, a tight schedule could mean difficulty in making out time to eat something nutritious. Because of the convenience shakes offer, you can easily store a serving in a bottle and mix it up whenever you want to drink it.

Best Meal Replacement Shakes

Beachbody Shakeology Shake

Beachbody Shakeology shakeShakeology is our #1 recommended meal replacement shake because it’s the most nutrient dense shake on the market. Shakeology combines the following core nutrient groups: proteins, superfrutis & antioxidants, prebiotics & probiotics, adaptogens, supergreens & phytonutrients, and vitamins & minerals.

Shakeology is low in sugar and contains absolutely NO artificial sweeteners, colors, flavors, nor preservatives. Instead, Shakeology is made with whole food ingredients and comes in nine different flavors. Even Vegan flavors.

Check out our Shakeology review here

SlimFast Advanced Energy

This meal replacement shake contains 5 g (0.17 oz.) of fiber and 20 g (0.70 oz.) of protein, helping you feel full for longer. In addition to this, it provides 24 essential vitamins and minerals, including zinc, calcium, riboflavin, vitamin A, folic acid, biotin, and vitamin D. These vitamins and minerals contribute to energy production in your body.

Nutrisystem Turbo Shake Chocolate Fudge

Each serving contains 5 g (0.17 oz.) of dietary fiber to help build and repair muscles. It also contains 15 g (0.52 oz.) of protein to keep you feeling satisfied. This meal replacement shake is made with a proprietary probiotic blend that supports digestive health and helps reduce belly fat.

Orgain Organic Nutritional Shake

Orgain Organic Nutritional Shake contains ten fruits and vegetables, 21 vitamins and minerals, and 16 g (0.56 oz.) of organic protein per serving. Moreover, it is free of preservatives, artificial flavors, gluten, and soy.

OWYN 100% Plant-Based Meal Replacement Shake

This meal replacement shake delivers 20 g (0.70 oz.) of protein, a mix of organic pumpkin seed, oat powder, organic flax oil, and pea. The protein plays an important role in the development of nails, skin, hair, and muscles.

This shake does not contain food allergens such as shellfish, fish, peanut, egg, and gluten. It is also devoid of artificial sweeteners and fillers and provides 23 vitamins and minerals.

Conclusion

While they’re not a long-term solution, meal replacement shakes are a good way to help you build lean muscle and reach your weight-loss goals.

However, not all shakes are made equal. Some meal replacement shakes contain unhealthy ingredients, such as chemical preservatives and corn syrup.

The best shakes are loaded with essential nutrients, protein, fats, carbohydrates, minerals, and vitamins, meaning you will be full for longer while getting the health benefits of a nutritious meal.

Therefore, you should make sure to choose a shake that is high in protein and low in artificial ingredients and sugar.

Sources

Julio

Before using meal replacement shakes and exercising, I was obese and on track to having high blood pressure at the age of 25. I'm glad to say I lost 50 pounds and am living a healthier lifestyle than before. Now I like sharing what I learned when I first researched what meal replacement to drink and the best way to lose weight. Learn more about me here...

Recent Posts